Anabaptist Theological Perspectives

Fervency & Burnout: A Sermon by Jerry Eicher

Join Jerry Eicher as he presents a compelling sermon from Oak Hill Mennonite, exploring the intricate relationship between fervency and burnout. This episode delves into the biblical story of Elijah, drawing parallels to modern experiences of spiritual zeal and exhaustion. Eicher provides insights into maintaining a fervent spirit while being mindful of the challenges that arise.Listeners will gain valuable perspectives on the balance between passion for one's faith and the reality of burnout, with practical advice and spiritual reflections. Discover how to rejuvenate your fervor without overextending, and learn from the experiences shared within this meaningful sermon.

Rethinking Mission Models: An Anabaptist Perspective

In this episode of Anabaptist Theological Perspectives, Jerry Eicher delves into the complex history and current state of Christian missions. Drawing from his own experiences in the third world, Eicher explores the traditional models of mission work under colonial powers like the British Empire, highlighting how political influences shaped the spread of Christianity across Asia, Africa, and the Pacific.
He critiques the political nature of modern missionary activities, likening them to historical colonial practices. Eicher argues that contemporary mission efforts often emphasize material aid over spiritual transformation, inadvertently wielding earthly power instead of focusing on genuine cultural engagement and spiritual growth.
The episode further examines how Anabaptist principles reject political entanglements in mission work, advocating instead for a model that empowers local communities to embrace Christianity through personal conviction and cultural adaptation. Eicher challenges listeners to reconsider the true role of political and material influences in spreading the gospel and calls for a return to a more spiritually-driven approach.

The Feminine Mystique: A Theological Review

In this thought-provoking episode of Anabaptist Theological Perspectives, host Jerry Eicher delves into a critical analysis of Betty Friedan's influential book, The Feminine Mystique. First published in 1963, the book played a seminal role in shaping the feminist movement and, consequently, had far-reaching effects on Western culture and the church.
Eicher explores the resurgence of opposition to feminism, highlighting voices inside and outside of institutional Christianity, such as Michael and Debbie Pearl's controversial ministry, No Greater Joy. He reflects on how the feminist agenda challenges traditional gender roles and impacts practices like the veiling of women in church.
This episode also uncovers the deeper theological implications of Friedan's work, drawing parallels between her call for a feminist awakening and the ancient biblical narrative of temptation and desire for more. Eicher seeks to engage listeners in a conversation about the destructive allure of seeking beyond divine provision, urging a return to spiritual truths.

Beyond Greek Philosophy: Reevaluating the Old Testament

In this episode of Anabaptist Theological Perspectives, Jerry Eicher explores the provocative ideas presented by Professor Brent Strawn from Duke Divinity School during a recent lecture series. The focus is on Strawn's proposal to read the Old Testament as poetry rather than as narrative, offering a fresh take on dealing with its inherent complexities.
Join us as we delve into Strawn's argument, contrasting it with historical approaches that have relied heavily on Greek philosophy to reconcile challenging passages. We examine the broader implications of abandoning the traditional narrative approach and embracing a poetic lens, alongside the critique of enduring Greek philosophical influences in Christian theology.
Eicher also reflects on the implications of such modern interpretations for the authority of scripture and the possible erosion of classical understanding within the academic realm. The discussion extends to the influence of figures like C.S. Lewis and Edward Fudge in reshaping current theological thought, questioning what comes next for Christian doctrine without the underpinnings of Greek philosophy and inviting consideration of how to navigate this brave, new intellectual landscape.

An Easter Poem

Join us for an enlightening episode as celebrate Easter with a poignant poem. Written and read at a sunrise service at Oak Hill Mennonite Church, the poem explores profound themes of redemption and suffering, shedding light on the unexpected nature of the divine. Expect a moving narrative about the Holy Writ, prophets' revelations, and the humble arrival of the servant of the Most High God.
This episode invites listeners to contemplate the incredible mystery of a God who bears humanity's griefs and sorrows, and the unexpected grace and salvation brought forth. Through this poetic journey, we reflect on the juxtaposition of worldly expectations and divine reality, underscoring the contrast between human perceptions of majesty and the true humility of a suffering savior. Join us in understanding why the Holy One of Israel is called our Redeemer in this inspiring Easter reflection.

Free Will and Determinism

Join Jerry Eicher as he delves into the complex and contentious topic of free will from an Anabaptist theological perspective. This episode begins the exploration of free agency and personal choice, emphasizing the Anabaptist belief in genuine self-agency to make free choices.
Eicher critiques the Calvinist viewpoint of predestination and shares his astonishment over its influence on Anabaptist churches, drawing from personal experiences within the Amish faith. The discussion also references John Piper's controversial stance and its implications for spiritual literature and preaching.
The discourse extends beyond religious boundaries, introducing insights from Robert Sapolsky's book "Determined," where the scientific argument against free will is analyzed. Eicher reflects on the academic concept of compatibilism, a position exploring the coexistence of determinism and free agency, which he finds enlightening and related to scriptural insights.
Listeners are invited to consider how these theological and philosophical discussions impact personal faith and real-world applications, leading to a call to engage with Eicher's recent sermon, "Work with what God has given you", as a further exploration of these themes.

"The New Birth: Anabaptist vs. Reformed Theology "

Join Jerry Eicher in an enlightening episode of "Exploring Further," where we delve into the profound theological debates surrounding the concept of new birth in Anabaptist and Reformed theology. This episode seeks to answer the complex question: Is the self totally depraved? Jerry argues in favor of the Anabaptist belief that a true believer experiences a literal new birth in Christ, contrasting sharply with Reformed perspectives that emphasize justification of the original self.
We explore insights from C.S. Lewis on the necessity of rebirth and critically analyze Reformed doctrine through the lens of Greek philosophical influences that suggest an uncorrupted soul. The discussion examines R.C. Sproul's rejection of certain Greek views, yet questions the embrace of others regarding the soul's nature. We also trace the historical perspectives of Augustine and Aquinas, and how these have shaped current theological thought.
This episode challenges listeners to reconsider the essence of the soul, the impact of sin, and the transformative power of rebirth through the Holy Spirit. Understand why the Anabaptist emphasis on a new self in Christ calls for a significant shift from traditional doctrines, making this a radically relevant dialogue for today's theological reflections.

"The Sanitization of the Old Testament: A Fresh Anabaptist Perspective"

In this thought-provoking episode, Jerry Eicher explores the controversial topic of why the Old Testament God has been sanitized within Christian theology. Delving into his Anabaptist background, Jerry contrasts traditional Anabaptist beliefs with the theological influence of figures such as Augustine and Thomas Aquinas. He discusses the deep-rooted impact of Greek philosophy on modern Christian thought and why it may have led to a 'sanitized' interpretation of Scripture.
Through personal anecdotes and academic insights, including quotes from esteemed scholar James Arieti, the episode unveils how the amalgamation of Greek philosophy with biblical teachings has shaped perceptions of God. Listeners are challenged to consider how historical attempts to reconcile the Bible with contemporary thought might dilute its original messages, specifically regarding the literal interpretations of the Old Testament.
Join Jerry Eicher as he calls for a return to a straightforward reading of the Scriptures, advocating a re-evaluation of theological doctrines in favor of embracing the true essence of the Old Testament. This episode offers a compelling analysis perfect for anyone interested in theology, historical influences, and the authenticity of Scripture.

Unlocking the Anabaptist "Born Again" Belief

In this enlightening episode, delve into the Anabaptist theological perspective on what it truly means to be "born again." While some might assume there is little distinction between Protestant and Anabaptist beliefs in this regard, we uncover the profound contrasts, particularly in how each tradition perceives regeneration and justification.
Join us as we start with the writings of Menno Simons, a pivotal figure in Anabaptism, whose teachings on regeneration as the ultimate goal of the gospel challenge the Protestant focus on mere justification. We explore how being "born again" is about becoming a new creature formed in the image and nature of Christ, a transformation far beyond merely being justified.
Then, we'll compare these foundational ideas with a more contemporary Mennonite Confession of Faith from 1963 and juxtapose them with a Baptist Confession of Faith from Capitol Hill Baptist Church in Washington, D.C. Through this comparative analysis, we unearth the enduring debate between justification and regeneration, showcasing how Anabaptist beliefs still present a radical alternative in Christian theology today.

Exploring Romans 10 & 11 - Breaking Free from Augustine

In this episode of "Unraveling the Gospel," Jerry Eicher delves deep into Romans chapter 10 with a unique adaptive theological perspective, rejecting traditional frameworks rooted in Augustine and Reformed theology. Eicher challenges the influence of ancient Greek philosophy on Christianity, arguing for a refined understanding of God that aligns better with scriptural teachings.
The core of the discussion revolves around the Apostle Paul's message to the Jews, emphasizing that zeal for God without understanding His righteousness leads to a misguided sense of self-worth. The episode underscores the transformative power of faith in Christ, compared to the law-based righteousness the Jews pursued.
Eicher highlights the Apostle's appeal to the Jews to recognize the righteousness freely given through belief in Christ, contrasting it with the righteousness derived from obeying the law. The narrative explains how faith in Christ's resurrection results in genuine salvation, transcending mere observance of law.
The discussion extends into Romans chapter 11, exploring the enduring relationship between God and Israel. Eicher emphasizes that God has not abandoned Israel despite their rejection, but instead uses other nations to provoke a return to faith.
Listeners are encouraged to understand God's broader redemptive plan, where He works beyond human limitations and preconceived theological notions, ultimately aiming for a unified understanding of His purposes across all nations.